The Best Places To Slurp Gelato In Florence

written by Tiana Kai
The Best Places To Slurp Gelato In Florence

Creamy, cool, potent pistacchio gelato is dripping down my pale hand while I’m trying to take this picture for you. Besides the sticky substance I’m also thinking that I should have gotten my nails done…

As much gelato as you may think I eat, I in fact have it on rare occasions, maybe once a month. That will change as of today and I’ll tell you why…

Not only is gelato amazing! BUT since the flavors change so often due to the change in seasons—even months at a time—there’s always something new to explore in the perfect world of tastebuds and cream.

When I do get tempted for a cone I try to have one from a different place every time, so that I can compare them and really do the hard working, finger licking, 2€ research for all of you!

Without further adieu, here is…

The best places to slurp gelato in Florence

It’s warm out and the tourists are already swarming the city. If you’re wandering on your own or find yourself on a tour, then get ready to stubble upon gelato everywhere and anywhere!

Just don’t eat the gelato from the main streets or from gelaterias with a display filled with abundant mounds of fancy looking gelato…that’s really just powder ‘n water.

In alphabetical order…

Badiani

Gelato in Florence

Yahoo, Badiani is by my house. It’s located in Le Cure, a neighborhood a tad northeast of downtown. It’s one of the most famous gelaterias—if not the most famous—in Florence.

What to get?! Why, their trademarked Buontalenti flavor, which is egg based cream and fresh whipped cream. You may have read about them in my 2-day food porn guide to Florence. I admit that I’ve had a midnight snack there once or twice!

Gelateria dei Neri

Gelateria dei Neri Best Gelato in Florence, Tuscany

People rave about Gelateria dei Neri and I for one agree on many accounts.

One, they freaking serve gelato. Two, the location is prime right on Via dei Neri 22r close to the best panini and my new favorite coffee bar!

I asked what their most famous flavor is and the woman looked at me like I was crazy, as if they make gelato that is NOT the best. So, according to her they’ll all blow your mind.

I opted for pistacchio—great and a bit milkier than others—and the fabulous ricotta and figs! Hurry over there since the figs are most definitely seasonal and one of my summer favorites.

Gelateria La Carraia

Gelateria La Carraia gelato in Florence

Come on, look at that view!

Gelateria La Carraia is located right off Ponte alla Carraia—Piazza Nazario Sauro 25—in the Oltrarno neighborhood by Piazza Santo Spirito.

I tend to get traditional flavors like pistacchio and fior di latte. Their cioccolato is intense too! If you’re not in the mood for a 1€ cone then opt for a gelato cake. Hey, you only live once!

Procopio

Procopio Best Gelato in Florence

Procopio—onVia Pietrapiana 60/62R—is incredible and the owners are the friendliest husband and wife team, Gianpaolo and Barbara. I came here on a Walks of Italy food tour and the tour ended with us in the back of the gelateria to see how they make it fresh every day…we may have gotten away with a few extra scoops.

What to get?! Well, their über famous almonds, pistacchio and candied orange slices. 

Let’s not forget pistacchio, since they have a creamy, non-milk sorbetto di pistacchio di Bronte DOP, meaning the pistacchi are guaranteed to be amazing and from the famous pistacchio area of Bronte, Sicily.

Rivareno

Rivareno Best Gelato in Florence, Italy

Rivareno is to die for! The first time I went here was after a fun bicycle tour; it was the perfect end to a 2 hour ride.

This place is a shot east of the duomo on Via degli Albizi 46. They protect their gelato in coolers, so don’t be bummed if you don’t see that crazy mound of gelato pouring all over the place. The metal cylinders keep the gelato at a perfect temperature before serving.

I love this place because it’s not overwhelming with too many flavors. They have the perfect mix of traditional like pistacchio—here we go again!—and more modern/seasonal flavors like orange, almonds, berries…

*Join in on my ridiculous hashtag on Instagram, it’s #YouSayIceCreamISayGelato!

What’s your favorite gelato flavor?! As you can tell I’m a diehard pistacchio fan! 

Loved this post? Then please share it and pin those pics!

26 comments

The Best Gelato in Florence, Italy | Life in It... May 27, 2014 at 3:48 pm

[…] Check out where to go to slurp on the best gelato in Florence, Italy. Pistacchio? Cioccolato? Fior di Latte? See which flavors are the best at each gelateria in Florence!  […]

Reply
Katie@From Shores to Skylines May 27, 2014 at 5:56 pm

We were practically obsessed with gelato in Italy. It’s so amazing, and not nearly as sweet as the ice cream I’m used to in the states (which is great thing!). My favorites were pistachio and hazelnut, sometimes chocolate (I’m a sucker for chocolate, but make an attempt to try something new every now and then). I’ll have to bookmark this for when I make it back to Florence!

Reply
Tiana Kai May 27, 2014 at 11:10 pm

Oh ya I love a good fondente! I’m sure that I would order chocolate if I hate gelato more often. Since it’s a once a month kinda treat I tend to try pistacchio at every location to see which has the best, and Procopio may have won, it’s a tough call!

Reply
Art Mad March 25, 2015 at 10:19 am

The Gelateria Antica in Via Faenza is great too. Try the formaggio e perre mixed with biscottini – drool!

Reply
Tiana Kai March 25, 2015 at 7:12 pm

Biscottini? Yum!

Reply
Cat of Sunshine and Siestas May 27, 2014 at 7:31 pm

STOP.

Reply
Tiana Kai May 27, 2014 at 11:08 pm

Well, I guess you have to come back to Florence to hit up all of these places!

Reply
Cassandra May 27, 2014 at 8:02 pm

Ahhh, Gelateria dei Neri was my hands-down favorite when I studied in Florence, so I’m glad to hear that it’s still setting the bar high. Reading through this whole list made me hungrier for Italy with every paragraph!

Reply
Tiana Kai May 27, 2014 at 11:07 pm

So great to hear you went there! I have heard about dei Neri for a long time now, so I’m glad that I got a few scoops myself.

Reply
Paige Miller May 28, 2014 at 11:39 am

My mouth is watering! I wish I would’ve known about these places when I was in Florence last summer.

Reply
Tiana Kai May 28, 2014 at 2:11 pm

You need to start planning your next trip then! 🙂

Reply
Kelly Michelle May 29, 2014 at 6:03 pm

I’m booking a flight to Florence!! I need more Gelato in my life and possibly some new Italian shoes! xx

Reply
Tiana Kai May 30, 2014 at 10:33 am

There’s always room for gelato and shoes!

Reply
Becky Padmore May 30, 2014 at 7:11 pm

Wow love this post, definitely need to get back to Italy soon! 😉

Reply
Tiana Kai May 31, 2014 at 2:41 pm

Thanks, it’s pretty nice to have all these great gelaterias a few blocks away from each other!

Reply
Birgitte Brøndsted June 2, 2014 at 9:17 am

Well, gelateria dei neri is my absolute favorite. Of the ones you list I actually only know Gelateria dei neri and Badiani, so I guess I have some research to do now. I would add Mordilatte in Via dei Servi to your list. So incredibly good…

Reply
Tiana Kai June 2, 2014 at 7:05 pm

Thanks for the tip, I also need to check out Carabè before I add it to this list as I heard it’s great!

Reply
Valeria June 12, 2014 at 1:25 pm

I would add at the top of the list Gelateria de Medici in Via dello Statuto, behind the Fortezza. There’s always a crazy line outside, but it’s really worth it!

Reply
Tiana Kai June 15, 2014 at 11:42 pm

Thanks, I’ve heard about Medici so need to definitely check it out!

Reply
Best Florence Restaurants, Eat like a Tuscan! June 15, 2014 at 11:41 pm

[…] Check out the top Gelaterias in Florence. […]

Reply
Coffee in Florence July 17, 2014 at 1:04 pm

[…] we just had to hobble half a block and there it was. The coffee haven. It’s also across from Gelateria dei Neri and close to the Arno River and Santa Croce. It’s like real estate […]

Reply
Living in Italy, how to do it the right way! August 7, 2014 at 10:31 pm

[…] living in Italy and breathing Italy for two years. There are so many amazing positives like food, gelato (no, I don’t consider this food, it’s too good to be considered anything but gelato!), […]

Reply
Massa Marittima To Do and See August 28, 2014 at 2:04 pm

[…] and salami, panzanella, pappa al pomodoro, crostini…—what’s a girl to do? Eat some gelato of course and take my quintessential #inmyhand shot! Nicco and I walked around the historical […]

Reply
lauradebenedetto September 2, 2014 at 3:53 am

the best gelateria in florence and one of the best in Italy is carapina (piazza oberdan) with only seasonal fruit and super-creams. my favourite in the summer is fresco carapina (milk and mint) with chocolate (nero carapina or traditional). slurp!

Reply
Tiana Kai September 5, 2014 at 12:50 pm

Yum, I heard this one is amazing too!

Reply
Favorite Gelato in Florence May 4, 2015 at 4:44 pm

[…] Visit Florence | Our Top Gelato Shops in Florence About Travel | Florence Favorite Gelato Shops Tiana’s Travels | The Best Places to Slurp Gelato in Florence […]

Reply

Leave a Comment